John,
Since you have asked and while I am waiting for delivery I figured I would weigh in on this subject, given the boat I have chosen was one of your contenders on OSJ. I had given considerable thought to the choice of what boat to buy. I was significantly constrained by size if I were to store it at my house. I started by considering 18-20 ft boats. Given the pressure by the spouse not to have a boat parked in the driveway I decided for off site storage. This somewhat alleviated my size constraint. Also given that I wanted a larger boat for offshore running, which my budget would allow. I began looking at 22-24’ boats. Used versus new. Parker, Farallon, Radon, Edgewater, etc. Many of my choices were ones you had on OSJ.
As I review my choices, I decide to go with a new boat. I did not want to get into a project where I basically was re-powering, updating electronics and fixing old plumbing and wiring. Not to mention some of the hidden issues with some older boats. Want to see some eye opening stuff take a look at www.Classiscmako.com and some of the restorations on that site. Some of those guys are really amazing. However, I have had enough of that with my house, and old cars. I want to go fishing.
I narrowed my choices down to the Edgewater (local dealer) and the Pacific 23 WA5 (again local dealer Tradewinds Inflatables). I went with the metal boat. She is currently under construction. One thing I will say about such a boat is how much it can be customized should you have the cash. I ordered my with 9.5 ft gunnel trays for fly rod storage. I also have a custom bow rail. I know that on OSJ you had rejected Pacific for cost for feature reasons. They definitely are a bare bones boat. Down sides of this boat are not a lot of nooks and crannies for storage like the Edgewater, no head, and under-deck storage, and concerns about electrolysis. For me the upsides were strong material, that is 30% lighter than a FG boat, easily repaired, no spider cracking and no concerns about electrolysis if rigged right. I got a walk around pilot house design and a more convenient stern entry for diving. A local dealership that will service the boat and engine and will help me customize the boat even after it has left the factory.
How she will be as a fly fishing platform is yet to be determined. Given that all boats are a compromise I hope she will do well by me on runs to SCI. She will be powered with the Honda 4S 225, and holds 114 gal of fuel. Offshore bait system and Furuno Electronics (NavNet 3D), including radar, GPS, and the digital FF, and decklights, are all on the list. Attached are some pictures of her in progress at the Pacific Factory in WA.
Richard
